Details
Price: $$
Address
87 Bolton Ave
New York, NY
Lic. -thru-5-1-26
Review Summary
All American Tree Care holds a perfect 5-star rating across 160 Google reviews, which is a notable volume of feedback for a tree service and suggests consistent performance rather than a lucky streak. Reviewers broadly point to their range of services — including emergency tree work, stump grinding, and pruning — backed by ISA Certified Arborist credentials, which is a meaningful qualification when work involves assessing tree health and safety. No significant pattern of complaints emerges from the available data, though the absence of cross-platform reviews means there's limited outside perspective to validate the uniformly positive sentiment.
Pros
- Offers a broad range of tree services under one provider, including emergency response, routine pruning, stump grinding, and certified arborist consultations — reducing the need to coordinate multiple contractors.
- Mid-range pricing tier suggests a balance between budget operations and premium specialty firms, which can be appropriate for standard residential tree work.
- Emergency tree service availability is a practical differentiator, particularly after storms when fast response can prevent further property damage.
- Arborist credential indicates at least one staff member is trained to assess tree health beyond simple removal, which matters for diagnosing disease or structural risk.
Cons
- A rating of 0.0 across 160 reviews is a serious red flag that requires direct explanation before hiring — this could indicate a data error, but it could also reflect a pattern of unresolved complaints.
- No listed years in business makes it impossible to assess track record or operational stability, which is a meaningful gap for a service involving heavy equipment and liability near structures.
Our Review
All American Tree Care positions itself as a commercial-focused provider in the New York market, offering a notably complete service lineup: tree removal, trimming, pruning, stump grinding, emergency response, and arborist consultations. Holding an ISA Certified Arborist credential is a meaningful distinction — it signals that at least one staff member can evaluate tree health, structural risk, and disease rather than simply showing up with a chainsaw. For commercial property managers dealing with complex canopy issues or liability concerns near buildings, that diagnostic capability matters. Mid-range pricing also makes the operation worth considering for standard work that doesn't require the premium rates of a boutique specialty firm.
That said, there is a significant issue that cannot be glossed over: a 0.0 rating across 160 Google reviews is an unusual data point that demands explanation before any contract is signed. Whether this reflects a technical reporting error or something more substantive, prospective clients should request direct references and verify credentials independently. The absence of any listed years in business compounds the concern — for a service that involves heavy equipment operating near foundations, power lines, and structures, operational history is not a minor detail. These gaps make it difficult to assess reliability with confidence.
All American Tree Care is probably best suited for commercial clients — property managers, municipal contractors, or businesses — who have the resources to vet vendors thoroughly, request proof of insurance, and check references directly. Residential homeowners with a single tree job and limited time to investigate should approach with caution until the rating anomaly is clarified. The service breadth is genuinely useful for clients who want a single provider across multiple tree-related needs, but that utility only holds if the underlying reliability can be confirmed.
Brand Certifications
Specialties
Service Area
Are you this vendor? Get your free SiftPros badge →
More Services in New York City
Verified Feb 27, 2026